Talk:No Man's Land

Page Name
I think this page should be moved to "No Man's Land", as it is the name of the planet in the manga and the upcoming anime i assumed because of episode 1s title. Anomixxx (talk) 03:35, 31 December 2022 (UTC)

I agree with Anomixx, the planet is never named in 1998 anime canon and "The Planet Gunsmoke" was only ever used as the title of the Kaiyodo toyline (and the lore printed on the toy packages themselves never referred to the planet with any name at all) and cancelled PS2 game. No Man's Land has been the only canon name of the planet and has been used in both the manga and 2023 anime now, which is 2 of the 3 versions of the show. This article is currently using a fanon name and is inaccurate. Whyitskai (talk) 00:06, 10 March 2023 (UTC)

I have renamed the page and removed all referenced to Gunsmoke, as well as making a few adjustments to the cities/towns listed as well as adding additional locations seen and/or mentioned in the 1998 anime. Whyitskai (talk)


 * Whyitskai, please next time don't rush to rename anything. When you start a discussion or reply to such, wait a few days for someone else to be able to say something. Its needed time for people to see and fact check what you are suggesting/stating. Additionally you made quite a mess with the page rename. Also if the name is used by PS2 game and toyline, then that is not a "fanon" name. Fanon names come from fans, not from official sources. (Unok (talk) 16:44, 11 March 2023 (UTC))

I'm sorry, I overstepped. please feel free to revert all my changes. I will argue that is fanon specifically for the 1998 anime as they never use a name for the planet in the show and I have yet to see it used in any official source materials for 1998 clearly stating as such. The packaging bios for The Planet Gunsmoke Toyline also do not name the planet at all, and appears to simply be a title. I could be wrong and again I apologize. I will refrain from making further edits. Whyitskai (talk)